Civil forfeiture is the fairly terrible idea that your property can seized by the government separately from the criminal justice process.
The City of Albuquerque has an aggressive program as described by the Institute for Justice here. The lede of the article:
"Arlene Harjo’s two-year-old silver Nissan Versa has sat for months in an
impound lot in Albuquerque—targeted by city officials for civil
Nobody claims Arlene violated the law. Instead, the city is trying to
take Arlene’s car because her son, Tino, allegedly drove drunk. Arlene
does not approve of drunk driving; if Tino broke the law, she agrees he
should be punished. But she does not see why she should be the one to lose her car."
Setting aside the obvious Constitutional issues, the problem with civil forfeiture is that it's a system that incentivizes government seizing private property. And anyone who has passed Economics 101 understands that people respond to incentives. This is why a program designed to punish drug dealers by seizing expensive assets like boats and cars evolved into a system that robs mostly ordinary (and mostly poor) citizens.
The Institute for Justice delves into the issue more deeply in the report, "Policing for Profit." So why talk about it on this blog? Wrongheaded programs like civil forfeiture destroy what little confidence people have left in local government. What Albuquerque is doing is more than unlawful; it's just plain wrong. Arlene Harjo deserves an apology, not just from the City of Albuquerque but from the profession of public administration for not speaking out more strongly.
One of the most important qualities a city manager or county administrator can possess is intellectual honesty . For a broader perspective,...
After arriving at Gonzaga University , I met my academic, a crusty Jesuit priest who told me: "The University can only teach you two ...
Civil forfeiture is the fairly terrible idea that your property can seized by the government separately from the criminal justice process. ...
The LA Times ran a story today (December 30, 2016) entitled, " When City Retirement Pays Better than the Job ." Featured promin...